Being told that your employer has concerns about your performance or capability can be difficult.

If, during that process, you are offered a Settlement Agreement, you may be wondering whether your employer has already decided to end your employment or whether you still have options.

Receiving a Settlement Agreement during a capability or performance process does not necessarily mean dismissal is inevitable. In many cases, employers use Settlement Agreements to explore whether an agreed exit would be preferable to continuing what can often be a lengthy and challenging formal process.

Before deciding whether to accept the offer, it is important to understand both your legal position and the alternatives available to you.

What is a capability process?

A capability process is a formal procedure used by employers where they believe an employee is unable to perform their role to the required standard.

This may relate to:

• Performance issues.
• Skills or competency.
• Attendance.
• Long-term ill health.
• Failure to meet agreed objectives.
• Inability to carry out the duties of the role.

Employers are generally expected to follow a fair procedure before dismissing an employee on capability grounds.

Why has my employer offered a Settlement Agreement?

There are many reasons why an employer may decide to propose a Settlement Agreement during a capability process.

For example, they may wish to:

• Avoid a lengthy formal procedure.
• Reduce the risk of future legal claims.
• Reach an agreed outcome that benefits both parties.
• Preserve a professional working relationship.
• Allow you to leave with financial support rather than continue through a potentially stressful process.

In some cases, the offer may reflect a genuine desire to reach an amicable agreement rather than continue with formal performance management.

Does accepting the agreement mean I admit poor performance?

No.

Signing a Settlement Agreement does not normally amount to an admission that you have performed poorly or that your employer’s concerns were justified.

Instead, it is an agreement that brings the employment relationship to an agreed conclusion on negotiated terms.

The wording of the agreement is important, particularly if future employers may ask about the circumstances in which your employment ended.

Your solicitor can advise whether any amendments should be made to protect your future career.

What if I disagree with my employer’s assessment?

It is not uncommon for employees to believe that capability concerns are unfair or unsupported.

For example, you may feel that:

• You have not received appropriate training.
• Your objectives were unrealistic.
• Other employees have been treated differently.
• You have not been given sufficient support.
• Your performance has been assessed unfairly.
• Personal circumstances have affected your work.

These issues may be relevant when assessing both your legal position and whether the proposed Settlement Agreement represents a fair outcome.

Can I negotiate a better package?

Possibly.

If your employer is keen to avoid continuing the capability process, there may be scope to negotiate improvements to the Settlement Agreement.

This could include:

• A higher compensation payment.
• An agreed employment reference.
• A different leaving date.
• Amendments to restrictive covenants.
• Confidentiality provisions.
• The wording used to describe your departure.
• Other practical arrangements that support your future employment.

Every case is different, and the opportunities for negotiation will depend upon your individual circumstances.

Should I continue with the capability process instead?

This is one of the most important decisions you will make.

In some situations, accepting a Settlement Agreement provides certainty, financial support and the opportunity to move on quickly.

In others, continuing with the formal capability process may be appropriate if you believe your employer has acted unfairly or if you wish to remain in your role.

There is no right answer that applies to every employee.

Before making a decision, it is important to understand:

• The strengths of your legal position.
• The risks of continuing the process.
• The value of the Settlement Agreement.
• Whether negotiation could improve the offer.

How Pepperells can help

Our specialist Employment Solicitors regularly advise employees who receive Settlement Agreements during performance and capability procedures.

We’ll:

• Review your Settlement Agreement.
• Explain your legal rights.
• Assess whether the capability process appears to have been conducted fairly.
• Advise whether the financial package appears reasonable.
• Explain your options.
• Negotiate improved terms where appropriate.

Our advice is tailored to your circumstances, helping you make an informed decision based on both the legal and practical implications of the offer.

Looking beyond the current situation

Receiving a Settlement Agreement during a capability process can feel personal.

However, many employees go on to build successful careers elsewhere.

A carefully negotiated Settlement Agreement can provide financial certainty, protect your professional reputation and help you move forward positively.

Before making any decision, it is worth taking the time to understand all of your options.

Speak to a Specialist Solicitor

If you’ve been offered a Settlement Agreement during a capability or performance process, Pepperells can help.

Our specialist Employment Solicitors will explain your legal position, review the fairness of the proposed agreement and advise whether accepting, negotiating or declining the offer is likely to be in your best interests.

Call Us Today | Request a Call Back